- 2006 -
| 1. | Munich | Steven Spielberg |  |
| 2. | Volver | Pedro Almodovar |  |
| 3. | V for Vendetta | James McTeigue |  |
| 4. | Enfermés dehors | Albert Dupontel |  |
| 5. | The Fountain | Darren Aronofsky |  |
| 6. | The Prestige | Christopher Nolan |  |
| 7. | Scoop | Woody Allen |  |
| 8. | Paris je t'aime | collectif |  |
| 9. | Little Miss Sunshine | Jonathan Dayton & Valerie Faris |  |
| 10. | Toute la beauté du monde | Marc Esposito |  |
- 2005 -
| 1. | Star Wars - Episode 3 - Revenge of the Sith | George Lucas |  |
| 2. | Le Château ambulant | Hayao Miyazaki |  |
| 3. | Angel-A | Luc Besson |  |
| 4. | Match Point | Woody Allen |  |
| 5. | Wallace & Gromit : the Curse of the Were-Rabbit | Nick Park & Steve Box |  |
| 6. | The Corpse bride | Mike Johnson & Tim Burton |  |
| 7. | Garden State | Zach Braff |  |
| 8. | The Life Aquatic (with Steve Zissou) | Wes Anderson |  |
| 9. | Before Sunset | Richard Linklater |  |
| 10. | Akoibon | Edouard Baer |  |